Vistry, however, has yet to fulfil much of the promise I had expected for it a year ago, and concerns over its unconsolidated debt led me to exit the position back in September. Other stocks held at the last year end that were sold down in 2025 included Interactive Brokers and Alphabet. Frustratingly, with the benefit of hindsight, I sold out from these wonderful businesses for reasons that don’t really fit with a strategy of owning winners for the long-term.
Shares in Interactive Brokers had gone from $85 to $200 in just over a year (using the prices prior to a 4:1 split in June 2025), which felt a little too good to be true. And although the founder seemed to think the business remained undervalued, I felt the multiple of current earnings looked a bit stretched. In addition, growth from crypto trading felt like it may be unsustainable, and driving some of the increase in valuation, so I sold out. As the shares are over $75 now (equivalent to $300 pre-split) and the business is growing extraordinarily well, with a long potential future growth runway still ahead, I feel that may have been one sale I will come to regret.
The other one that I may come to regret selling is the (also relatively small within the portfolio) position in Alphabet, which was also done in February of last year. At that point, as I recall, it felt like Google Search may be disrupted by the rise of alternative search methods, as LLMs gave comprehensive answers to prompts. However, by the end of 2025 the best LLM seemingly, was one run by Google. And for all the fanfare over how search could be disrupted, it looks like the champion of search remains the incumbent. Meanwhile – if my kids are anything to go by – YouTube is approximately as addictive as crack cocaine (I haven’t tested them on both, so I can’t be sure) and looks set to be the dominant streaming service of the decade alongside Netflix.
On a more positive note, a business I had been vaguely following for about 16 years (the benefits of being a little older and a little wiser than when I started out) saw its shares fall on the back of tariff-related concerns. The business has fantastic returns on capital, a great record of growth, allocates all the (limited) capital it needs to grow the business and then pays the rest out to shareholders. And it is too small to be on most professional investors’ radars. The firm called 4Imprint (ticker: FOUR) and happily the shares have started to bounce nicely from my first entry point in April and continued purchases over the summer.
The portfolio’s performance in 2025, for the most part, was driven by movements in UK bank shares. OSB recovered and I exited for an overall gain of 33%. I held shares in Vanquis (sadly only a relatively tiny position) for five months realising a gain of 112% over that period. I ‘recycled’ some profits in Close Brothers – post the Supreme Court’s ruling – into Secure Trust Bank (with impeccably bad timing, as it turns out, in mid-August) and then doubled my position size as a short-term wobble took the shares swiftly down by 25% in a week almost straight after the initial purchase. Fortunately, STB shares had bounced back by the end of the year.
Whilst not ‘quality’ or ‘compounders’ the distressed valuations in the above small cap banks offered up opportunities that I expected would work out well. I realise now – more than ever – that for ‘value’ ideas to work when they are in lower quality businesses, they really have to work quickly, or the overall returns will end up becoming unattractive. In addition, you really have to be buying into a wave of pessimism and – ideally – selling into a wave of optimism to achieve a good overall investment return, as the lowly returns on capital being generated by the business are not going to do the heavy lifting for you.
Meanwhile, by owning shares in wonderful businesses purchased at reasonable prices, you really only have to be right about the quality of the business and, over time, the high returns and business growth will become the dominant factor in the returns generated by the investment, as opposed to the levels of anxiety or excitement driving the decisions of your opposing counterparty when transacting in the stock market.
Despite still not having found my way to simply owning great businesses for the long-term, the portfolio has had a good run of late. Since inception in March 2005, the annualised return is now 19.3%, for a total return of 3,886%, against 337% for the FTSE 100 (7.3% annualised) and 746% for the S&P 500 (10.8% annualised). The portfolio’s gain in 2025 was 47.4% - the third best calendar year return since inception.

